Review: My Brilliant Friend

Review: My Brilliant Friend

Posted by Jenny Booth | 28 March 2017 | Arts & Culture, Reviews

The outstanding production of My Brilliant Friend at the Rose Theatre is a marathon achievement for everyone involved, audience included.

It is five hours long; it is possible to see the two halves on different nights, but it was worth the numb behind to experience the gigantic story unfolding in its entirety, playing out half a century in the life of a Naples slum gripped by a ferment of change.

Lila and Lenu

Lila and Lenu.

The story tells of the emotional struggle of two unusual, intelligent women to stay friends, when so many factors – poverty, family, politics, and their love for the same man – seem bent on pitting them against one other.

It is an act of extreme daring, to adapt four novels so acclaimed that their mysterious author Elena Ferrante has been named one of the 100 most influential people in the world.

At 16 Lila marries shopkeeper Stefano as a way to escape family drudgery and be worshipped

At 16 Lila marries shopkeeper Stefano as a way to escape family drudgery and be worshipped.

Conveying all the huge array of characters was impossible with a small ensemble cast, and many scenes well loved by the books’ devoted fans had to be cut.

The act of compression showed in some places, as plot lines just broke off and complex events were portrayed by mime sequences.

Lila tries to drive away local gangster Marcelo Solara

Lila tries to drive away local gangster Marcelo Solara.

And yet, taken as a whole, the production works amazingly well. By the end I was confounded, and felt battered by emotion. I was filled with admiration for Niamh Cusack and Catherine McCormack’s for their passionate portrayals of the very different lead characters. I had become caught up in the lives of Lenu and Lila.

Politics threatens to divide working class Lila from Lenu, a bourgeoise academic

Politics threatens to divide working class Lila from Lenu, a bourgeoise academic.

McCormack’s Lila is an over-confident street urchin with a hoarse, cawing voice and exaggerated nonchalance, hiding the volcanic emotion and razor judgement inside. Cusack’s Lenu is more mellifluous, a people-pleaser who often defers to or copies her feistier friend, yet grows ruthless as she develops her own sense of identity.

Lila with Nino Salvatore, who both women love

Lila with Nino Salvatore, who both women love.

At a Q&A session with the cast, the actors spoke of the marathon of staging both plays consecutively, the athletic feats needed to switch character within seconds, and the exhaustion they felt by the end; but also the satisfaction of bringing the whole to the stage in one go.

Lila and Lenu's youngest children are portrayed by puppetry

Lila and Lenu’s youngest children are portrayed by puppetry.

Rehearsals were a dynamic process of distilling the books’ essentials, they said, with key scenes being cut and others added until late on, to try to keep the narrative balanced.

For days after, the play’s dilemmas continued to occupy my thoughts. Why did Lenu defy Lila? Who was really the stronger of the two? Where is Lila?

Lenu and Lila as young children

Lenu and Lila as young children.

It is an accolade to all involved that this gigantic, tragic story made it to the stage with such triumphant success.

My Brilliant Friend runs at the Rose Theatre in Kingston until April 2. Book now.

By ‘Culture Vulture’ Jenny Booth
Twitter: @culturevult
Facebook: @culturevult

Jenny Booth
About The Author

Jenny Booth

Jenny was a news journalist for The Times. An ex-teacher, mum, gardener and art lover, there’s nothing she doesn’t know about the local culture scene…

Now read this...

Posted by Eyes of Lady Wimbledon | 19 February 2020
Historic Tales of Cannizaro Park
Writer Trevor P Kwain discovered that SW19 has an amazing back story, much of which is untold. Here he shares the facts he uncovered whilst writing his novel...
Posted by Janie Smith | 14 February 2020
Tales of Family and Friendship – February’s Book Club for Kids
February is the month of love, but it shouldn’t be just for adults. Fire up your children’s imaginations with our fabulous family and friendship stories chosen especially for them. Max...
Posted by Janie Smith | 22 January 2020
New 2020 Books for Wintery Nights
By now we are all settling into the new year and indeed decade. It’s been a cold couple of weeks, so it really is time to grab some calm amidst...


Join Lady W’s VIP list for exclusive event invites and more